The difference between ODD and PDA

One of the questions that comes up again and again is this: what is the difference between Oppositional Defiance Disorder and Pathological Demand Avoidance? Usually it comes from a parent trying to work out what is happening to their child, because what they are seeing looks extreme. They are worn down, they are trying to understand, and they are reading everything they can find about oppositional or defiant behaviour. Or they asked for help and a professional told them their child shows signs of ODD. That happens very often when the child already has an ADHD or autism diagnosis. Then the parent reads a bit more, or lands in a Facebook group for ADHD or ASC, and someone mentions PDA. That is the point where their head threatens to come off.
Why are there so many letters? What on earth is the difference between being oppositional and being demand avoidant? Is one worse than the other? The PDA description sounds exactly like my child, but they are not autistic, are they — wait, are they? I have been there. I was there. So the answer I give every time is that it is a good question, and then I try to explain in a comment and make a mess of it, because there is a great deal to say and a comment box is not the place. It was one of the first questions I needed answering myself. When I realised my son's struggles went past what I would call developmentally and emotionally typical — and I had been studying child development for well over twenty years — my first searching led me to ADHD and ODD. It almost fitted him. I could have stopped there. ADHD certainly fitted me and my eldest daughter, but something was off. A colleague, a friend now, kept sharing things about PDA, and every time she did my mind was blown. It explained my life, and it explained my son.
Before I get to the similarities and the differences, let me give a short description of each so we know what we are comparing. I will be skimming the surface. There are links to more detail where you need them.
Oppositional defiance disorder (ODD)
Criteria
For a diagnosis of ODD a child needs a pattern of disruptive behaviour, with at least four symptoms from the following categories.
- Angry or irritable mood: loses their temper often, is touchy or easily annoyed, is often angry and resentful.
- Argumentative or defiant behaviour: argues with adults, actively defies or refuses to comply with requests from authority figures or with rules, deliberately annoys other people, blames others for their own mistakes or misbehaviour.
- Vindictiveness: has been spiteful or vindictive at least twice in the past six months.
The pattern has to last at least six months, and it has to involve at least one person who is not a sibling.
Risk factors and cause
ODD is thought to be “caused” by a combination of things, in the way mental health conditions and personality disorders are usually understood: a hereditary pre-disposition, with environmental factors doing a large part of the work. The risk factors usually listed are one or more of these.
- a harsh or inconsistent parenting style
- parental mental health problems, depression or substance misuse
- adverse childhood experiences, including abuse, parental loss or a parental break-up
- poverty
- consistent criticism in one or more settings
- the presence of other mental health problems
- unrecognised, untreated or badly managed neurodivergences, ADHD or autism among them
Pathological demand avoidance (PDA)
Criteria
For a child to be recognised as having a PDA profile, the following characteristics are looked for.
- resisting and avoiding demands from other people, from themselves, and the demands that are simply expected of everyone every day
- needing to be in control
- using social strategies to avoid and resist demands while keeping control
- lability of mood, meaning mood changes quickly and dramatically between extremes
- impulsivity
- taking great comfort from internal role play and fantasy, sometimes using it to hide difficulties
- being social by nature but struggling to maintain social relationships
- being obsessive in their interests, and sometimes becoming obsessed with people
- showing characteristics of other neurodivergences, including differences in sensory processing, executive function and emotional regulation
In a meltdown a PDA child can be extremely aggressive, verbally abusive and violent. Some PDAers never show that behaviour at all, and turn the anxiety inwards instead.
Risk factors and cause
PDA is currently considered a profile of the autism spectrum. My understanding is that there is some uncertainty about that, but what is clear is that it is a neurological difference, a neurodivergence. What causes neurodivergences is not settled, and a good deal of research is still going on. The current thinking is a strong genetic component, with some environmental influence on the developing brain in the womb. Social factors are not thought to play a part.
How they are similar
The two profiles can look very alike, and they can be hard to tell apart from the outside. You have a child in front of you who flatly refuses to do as they are told, and who becomes violent or aggressive if you press them. If the child is also ADHD, as most children diagnosed with ODD are, then impulsivity, emotional regulation, executive function and sensory issues will be in the mix too, and ADHD brings social difficulty of its own because of the impulsivity and the attention. The co-occurrence of ADHD with PDA is also much higher than in the general population. It is easy to see why parents end up confused and frustrated. I was. Now let me look at where the two actually differ.
Where the two part company
The reason behind the behaviour
For a child with ODD, the behaviour is understood to come out of a persistent, pervasive state of negative thinking and negative emotion. That state has roots in very difficult experience, or in an environment of relentless negativity at home or at school, and it can set a negative frame of mind as the child's normal. Research shows, for instance, that ADHD children are on the receiving end of considerably more criticism than neurotypical children. What triggers the ODD child is the perceived source of that negativity: authority. The result is emotional fragility, persistent anger and annoyance, a low tolerance for people, and frequent confrontations with anyone in a position of authority. ODD is a childhood behaviour profile which, if it continues, can develop into an adult conduct disorder.
For the PDAer, the behaviour is understood to come from a difference in the wiring and chemistry of the brain, which, among other things, sets off a threat response when the person meets a demand. I think it would be more accurate to say the response is triggered by any perceived threat to their autonomy, but that is a subject for another day. The key point is that demands of every kind send the PDAer into fight, meaning aggression and violence, flight, meaning avoidance taken to extremes, or freeze, meaning shutdown.
Social interaction
An ODD child may have come to see other people as a source of great annoyance, which feeds the negative self-talk and the negative emotion and produces the anger. A PDA child tends to love being around people and will seek them out, even though they cannot cope for long with the demands that socialising brings. They may try to control social situations and become frustrated when they cannot, and the anxiety that follows can show up as anger if nobody spots it early.
Mood
A child with ODD will hold fairly consistent negative emotion, to a greater or lesser degree, at any given time. A PDAer is more likely to switch moods without warning and to experience emotions that come and go — a sudden flip, then back to being fine reasonably quickly. A PDAer can swear at, scream at and threaten the people they love in order to avoid a demand, and then, once the demand is gone and as long as the meltdown has not happened, be calm and affectionate again. That is not manipulation. It is genuine terror arriving and then subsiding. An ODD child will stay angry and resentful for longer. The PDAer is also likely to be full of remorse after a meltdown, because a meltdown is, by its nature, a total loss of control. An ODD child is less likely to feel remorse and more likely to have stayed in control of what they were doing, though not always.
Defiance, demand avoidance and pathological demand avoidance
So what makes the defiance different? This is the tricky part. Every human being can be defiant, and every human being can avoid demands, which means both children can show both behaviours. That is also what makes it understandable. We have all felt that we do not want to do what the person in front of us has told us to do, because we are angry inside, or angry with them, or angry about the task itself. When we refuse on those grounds we are being defiant, and the refusal is driven by anger. Usually we say no outright, or we get visibly and outwardly cross.
We have also all felt that we do not want to do something, or cannot do it, for reasons that have nothing to do with anger. Exhaustion, no motivation, or apprehension about how complicated or how long the task is. Have you ever left an essay until the last minute? That apprehension can grow into something more extreme, and be better described as anxiety. Avoiding things because they make us anxious is typical. In some people, including people with mental health difficulties and neurodivergences, particular tasks and activities — phone calls, going outdoors, social gatherings, complicated organisational work — are anxiety-inducing, and those people will go to much greater lengths to avoid them. All of this counts as demand avoidance, and it is driven either by lack of motivation, by lack of executive function, or by something that causes anxiety.
PDA is described with the P because the avoidance in a PDAer is abnormal, atypical, extreme and pervasive. A PDAer does not only avoid demands that make them anxious. The PDAer's anxiety is caused by the demand being there in the first place. Telling them, asking them, reminding them, begging them, even gently expecting something of them, all produce utter panic — and so does expecting something of themselves.
I keep struggling to put the feeling into words, but I will try. I am a black belt in Taekwondo. I love it, and the classes genuinely help my mental health. I enjoy them. And still I fight myself every single time it is a Taekwondo day, arguing in my head with my own PDA. My threat system is telling me that everyone expects me to go, myself included, and that I have to resist at all costs. I have to fight it with everything I have, because I want to go. If somebody reminds me to get ready, it feels as though a brick wall has appeared in front of me, and my brain screams STOP. DANGER. FIGHT. RUN.
As you can see, that is a long, slow internal struggle, and it can tip over into something unmanageable without warning. I am an adult, so mostly I fight with myself, but when I am pushed I will use every strategy going to avoid a demand: distraction, procrastination, incapacitating myself, making excuses, and on it goes until it is all too much. My meltdowns are hours of sobbing or visible panic attacks, and sometimes shutdown instead.
The differences, side by side
All of that is a lot to hold in your head, so here is the same material set out next to itself.
Pathological demand avoidance
- a neurological difference
- lability of mood
- perceives demand as a threat
- avoids many kinds of demand, including things they want to do and everyday activities
- uses social strategies to avoid demands, escalating before meltdown
- shows a great deal of remorse after extreme avoidant behaviour and after meltdown
- present from birth, though not always obvious
- shows extreme anger in fight mode
- has executive function, sensory and emotional regulation differences
Oppositional defiance disorder
- a negative cognitive and emotional pattern
- persistent anger and annoyance
- perceives authority as a threat
- avoids things they do not want to do, things they are afraid of, or requests that make them angry
- uses refusal and aggression to defy authority figures
- shows little or no remorse for defiant behaviour
- triggered by difficult life situations
- struggles to control anger and annoyance
- sensory and executive function differences only where a neurodivergence is also present
A quick test
Now that the pattern is a little clearer, there is one observation that can help a great deal in working out which of the two you are dealing with: how the child responds to rewards and to imposed consequences. That response is a good indicator.
A child with ODD will often respond well to increased external motivation. If they can see the point of the task, even if they would rather not, they will often comply. So if you want an ODD child to tidy their room, offering a new Lego set, or telling them they will not be going out on their bike tomorrow, will make it more likely that the room gets tidied. I have researched motivation closely enough to want to say that this approach to parenting, widely accepted as it is, does not serve anyone well in the long run. That is also a subject for another day. In the short term, with an ODD child, it usually gets the result.
Now offer the same thing to the PDAer who is refusing to tidy their room, and watch the meltdown. The threat hanging over them, or the reward dangling in front of them, will not motivate them. It will raise their anxiety to a level they cannot manage. All you have done is multiplied the demand of that activity by ten, or by more, depending on the weight of the threat or the value of the reward.
A note on anxiety and struggling children
Reading this may leave you thinking that ODD describes a child we would traditionally call naughty, and PDA does not. That is not what I am saying. To begin with, I think the word naughty, and every derivative of it, is loaded and unhelpful at any time. Children show good behaviour when they are able to. If they are showing difficult behaviour, they are struggling. The evidence is very clear that whichever difficulty sits behind the behaviour, both the ODD child and the PDA child are struggling, and both need compassion and loving care.
Why it matters
What matters is that compassionate parenting looks quite different depending on what is happening for your child. Put simply, the ODD child needs firm boundaries and limits, held with a high level of empathy and compassion, appropriate positive reinforcement, and a great deal of consistency and connection. Demands do not have to be reduced, and communication can be direct, as long as the child is handled gently.
The PDA child needs a flexible approach, plenty of autonomy, a low-demand or no-demand environment, collaborative problem-solving without extrinsic rewards, very careful management of communication and praise, and an individual approach to their sensory needs.
Both children need adults around them who genuinely understand their situation and have empathy for it. Both can be extremely hard to live with and to raise. Both need us to deal with our own issues so that we can do the best for them. Whichever one you are dealing with, I know you are doing the very best you can, because you have taken the time to read this far. Thank you from me, and thank you from the child who may never find the words to say it.
Keep learning, and keep trying to see the world through their eyes.
Tomlin Wilding
If you have a comment on what I have written, or a simple question, please leave it below. If this has brought up a lot of questions, or worries about your child or yourself, or you have had an emotional reaction to reading it, send me a message and we can discuss it. I also keep a list of services for anyone who wants personalised education or support.
Rise up with me
Consultations, training and collaboration for families, schools and organisations.